The other day after I got home from the open house of the new kindy and told hubby about it, he asked if I’ve planned to enrol JS there ( he didn’t know that I’m actually surving it for WH instead of JS) I told him No. As much as I have strong believes on the montessori method of teaching, I know it wont work for kids age 5 and above in M’sia. JS will have to go to a conventional school with chinese medium to prepare her for primary one.
Many people who have no knowledge of Malaysia education system and also my hubby will have the misconception of my remark. “Huh? You mean montessori is only for 2 1/2 to 3?” and my hubby will think that after spending so much money on sponsoring my course, it’s a waste as I can only apply the method on a 2 – 3 yrs old.
Many people have this misconception about Montessori method always end up thinking that it’s lousy because there are parents remark that the kids who attended montessori are not able to pick up when they enter public primary school in malaysia. Parents only see the result and never really look into the root cause and parents who make that remarks surely do not have the appreciation and understanding of the method and philosophy. (By the way it’s almost impossible to find a full montessori school that caters to K1 & K2 in Malaysia, the school cleary understand our public education system and that a full montessori will not prepare the kids to meet the standard due to many factors and restriction of our education system)
In the US, a Montessori school can go up till the kids in 15 yrs old. There’s where the teachers go for advanced diploma or degree in the montessori method of teaching. So it’s not just limeted to toddlers.
Before hand, I naively thought that I can find a full montessori school in M’sia, but as I know more, I know they are basically non existent.
There might be school that applys the montessori method of teaching maths and languange in K1 and K2, but it will not be full Montessori. Why is that so? The rules and regulations stated that all kindy have to strictly follows the NPC ( national pre-school curriculum) and K1 and K2 is the vital prepatory years for the kids to enter to primary one. The KBSR is still a very conventional way of learning and it’s very much teacher’s oriented. If a kids is attending a full montessori pre-school, it’s very likely he will be left behind when enters Primary one.
This does not show that Montessori method is slow, but because majority of parents in malaysia only start to sent their kids to school at age 5. Many M’sia parents will think that by sending a kids to a playschool at the age of 2 1/2 is too early and a waste of money. I use to have a mindset like that. Why take away their childhood by sending them to school so early. Even some parents think that by sending their kids to school at age 4 is early. I will agree so if the kids is sent to a conventional school which is so stressful, but if there is a chance to be in a true montessori school, it’s best to start as early as possible.
There are so many didantic materials in a montessori curriculum. If parent only start to sent the child to a montessori school at age 5, the child wont be possibiliy having enough time to go through all the materials. Take for example language, if sanndpaper letters is only introduced to a kids of age 5, it might take half a year for the child to master all the phonetic sound of the letters before the child is ready for word building activities with LMA. There are so many levels in the pink series and then later the blue, grammers and the green. That’s why it’s impossible to finish off till the green series in just a mere 2 years time of education. If a child is only reaching a basic level in pink series at age 6 , certainly he will be left out when he enters primary one.
Montessori method emphasized alot of individual development and according to the kids own development phase. There is no pushing and rushing. The child is given a chance to master an activity before moving on to the next higher level at their own phase. If a kids only start school at age 5, there is certainly no time for the kids to master and work with all the materials in all area. With the short period of time frame (2 years), it’s impossible for a kids to developed to a phase in a montessori way that he’s able to cope with the Malaysia education system in year one. ( of course if given a chance of exposure at age 2 1/2 and consitent teaching of montessori method till age 6, the kids will go beyond the level of our primary one standard)
Pre-school time in M’sia is short. Only 3 hours per day and 5 days a week. Each day minus off 1/2 snack time. And there are so much other things in the NPC to be added in like moral, islam studies, computer, art & craft , music, mandarin, malays, physical activity, circle time …there seems to be not much time left for montessori materials (which consists of 5 areas and many levels and activities) . Not to forget about concert and sports day preparation…. 4 times a year of exam (yes, even in pre-school there’s exam and that lasted almost 4 days each time). Class size in M’sia is usually big. Added on with the limited hours it’s almost impossible for the teacher to have individual focus on the kids and to give the kids time to progress on their own phase. That’s why conventional teaching is applied in K1 & K2, which is like a crash prepatory for the kids to enter primary one.
During the training, the materials at the training centers and that we have learned is actually caters for children from age 2 1/2 to 6. When we reach the almost last stage of the materials, the lecture would say ” by the time the child reach this stage, they would have left school already” It clearly shows that our school system just wont allow and dont have the time to go through with all the materials.
I have a kindy teacher friend that told me , if the kindy has a kid that enter K2 in a new school year and prior to that has never attended any pre-school before, the kindy teacher will start to worry for the child. They worry that the child not able to catch up in primary one and crash course and alot of drilling and pushing is given in that K2 year. Isn’t that more stressful for a kid?
Sadly this is the fact of our education system where it’s like a rat race , the kids is expected to be on a certain level and perform accordingly. What a stressful life to have schooling in M’sia that we are not developing a wholistic individual of the next generation.
With that I give up hope on JS ever to have a chance to be in a Montessori school.